Erwin Smith asks hundreds of soldiers to die for humanity while he chases a private dream. In Attack on Titan, Hajime Isayama brings that dream within reach and then has him ride away from it.
In Chapter 80 of Attack on Titan, “The Nameless Soldiers,” Commander Erwin Smith has one plan left. The Beast Titan, an enemy Titan with a human mind, is destroying his army from a distance with volleys of thrown rock. Erwin and the newest recruits can charge it on horseback as a distraction, and all of them will die, so that Captain Levi can get close enough to kill it (Attack on Titan Wiki: Chapter 80).
He has not given the order, and he tells Levi why. The basement of Eren Yeager’s house is in the district they are fighting over. It may hold the truth about their world, and Erwin has wanted that truth since he was a boy. Levi kneels in front of him, tells him he has fought well, and makes the choice for him: “Give up on your dream and die” (CBR). Erwin smiles.
Soldiers die in almost every arc of Attack on Titan. Erwin’s death carries a different weight because the reader knows exactly what he gives up when he rides out. Hajime Isayama spent nearly thirty chapters making sure of it.
Isayama then tests the sacrifice a second time. Four chapters later, Levi holds a single injection that can bring one dying soldier back, and Erwin is one of two candidates. Together, the two scenes show how to write a sacrifice that costs the character something the reader can see.
Who Is Erwin Smith?
Attack on Titan (Shingeki no Kyojin, 進撃の巨人) takes place in a world where humanity lives inside three concentric Walls named Maria, Rose and Sina. Outside are the Titans, giant humanoids that attack and eat people on sight. The story begins in the year 845, when two Titans breach Wall Maria at Shiganshina District, the hometown of the protagonist, Eren Yeager (Wikipedia: Attack on Titan).
Erwin Smith (エルヴィン・スミス) is the 13th commander of the Survey Corps, the military branch that fights Titans beyond the Walls. The anime’s English version calls it the Scout Regiment. He is a shrewd strategist who gambles on unorthodox plans and makes hard choices that cost his soldiers’ lives (Wikipedia: List of Attack on Titan characters). When Eren turns out to have the power to become a Titan, Erwin plans to use that power to retake Wall Maria and reach the basement of Eren’s house in Shiganshina. Eren’s father had said the truth about their world was kept there.
Erwin Smith’s Story, Explained
What Is Erwin Smith’s Dream?
To learn the truth about the world and prove his father right. Erwin’s father was a teacher. As a boy, Erwin asked a question in class about the history of the Walls, and his father answered it at home with a theory: the king had altered humanity’s memories when people first moved inside the Walls. Erwin repeated the theory to other children. His father then died in what was officially an accident, and Erwin later learned that the Military Police had arranged it (Attack on Titan Wiki: Erwin Smith).
How Did Erwin Lose His Arm?
In Chapter 49 (anime Episode 36, “Charge”), Erwin leads the mission to rescue the kidnapped Eren, and a Titan bites off his right arm. He orders his soldiers to keep advancing while the Titan carries him away (Attack on Titan Wiki: Erwin Smith in the anime).
What Chapter and Episode Does Erwin Die In?
Erwin is mortally wounded in the charge that begins in Chapter 80 and dies in Chapter 84, “Midnight Sun.” In the anime, the charge is in Season 3, Episode 16, “Perfect Game” (Episode 53 overall), and his death is in Season 3, Episode 18, “Midnight Sun” (Episode 55). Both aired in 2019 (Wikipedia: Attack on Titan season 3). Hange Zoë succeeds him as the 14th commander.
Why Did Levi Choose Armin Over Erwin?
Levi decides to let Erwin rest. He first intends to use the serum on Erwin, the person he believes will save humanity. Then the dying Erwin raises his hand as if he were back in his father’s classroom and asks how anyone knows there are no humans outside the Walls. Levi gives the serum to Armin Arlert instead. Afterward, Levi says that Erwin became a devil because that was what the Corps needed of him, and that it was time to let him rest (Attack on Titan Wiki: Midnight Sun episode).
What Was in the Basement?
Three journals left by Eren’s father, hidden under a false bottom in a desk drawer. Inside the first is a photograph with a note stating that humanity outside the Walls has not died out (Attack on Titan Wiki: Chapter 85). The survivors open the drawer one chapter after Erwin dies.
A Selfless Commander With a Selfish Reason
For most of the series, Erwin appears to want one thing, humanity’s survival, and he spends lives and his own right arm to get it. Isayama reveals the private motive under that duty in four steps.
The smile. In Chapter 51 (anime Episode 37, “Scream”), Hange and Connie Springer bring evidence that Titans are transformed humans. Levi is troubled that he may have spent years killing people. Erwin smiles, and when Levi asks about it, he says humanity has come one step closer to the truth (Attack on Titan Wiki: Scream). Isayama has said he had trouble deciding how to portray Erwin, and that the character came alive for him when he drew that reaction (Attack on Titan Wiki: Erwin Smith).
The father. In Chapter 55 (anime Episode 40, “Old Story”), Erwin tells the story of his father’s theory and death (Attack on Titan Wiki: Chapter 55). The commander who orders soldiers to their deaths believes his own words got his father killed.
The admission. In Chapter 72 (anime Episode 49), on the eve of the mission to retake Wall Maria, Levi wants the one-armed Erwin to stay behind and threatens to break his legs. Erwin concedes that Levi is probably right and refuses anyway. He has to be there when the truth about the world is revealed. Levi is surprised that this matters more to Erwin than humanity’s victory over the Titans (Attack on Titan Wiki: Chapter 72). Before they leave, Erwin entrusts the Corps’ only dose of Titan serum to Levi (Wikipedia: Attack on Titan season 3).
The confession. In Chapter 80, with the basement in the same district and his army dying around him, Erwin says all of it out loud.
Isayama has described the split directly. In an interview for the 2017 guidebook Attack on Titan Character Directory, quoted by ComicBook.com from a fan translation, he said Erwin wavered between the roles of “a child who chased his dream” and “an adult who carried responsibilities.” To affirm his identity, Isayama said, Erwin “fabricated the false ambition of fighting ‘For humanity’s future’” (ComicBook.com). By the author’s own account, the public cause was the cover and the private dream was the truth.
The Dream Within Reach
A sacrifice is the surrender of one valued thing for another, so the reader has to know what is being surrendered. Isayama arranges Chapter 80 so that Erwin’s dream is nearly in reach at the moment his duty becomes most expensive.
The mission’s goal is the basement, and the Corps is already fighting in and around Shiganshina. Then the Beast Titan’s bombardment pins Erwin and the recruits against the Wall. The only plan that can work requires Erwin to die leading it, because the recruits will not ride to their deaths unless he rides in front (Attack on Titan Wiki: Chapter 80).
Erwin admits that only his wish to live long enough to see the basement has stopped him from acting. He tells Levi he can feel their fallen comrades watching him (Attack on Titan Wiki: Erwin Smith), and he asks whether his dream was a childish delusion (Attack on Titan Wiki: Perfect Game).
Isayama has explained why the confession comes here. He drew the scene, he said, around the idea that “the moment humans reveal their truest nature is when they have been pushed to the brink of death” (ComicBook.com).
The idea is one of the oldest in dramatic theory. Aristotle wrote in the Poetics that “Character is that which reveals moral purpose, showing what kind of things a man chooses or avoids” (Poetics, S. H. Butcher translation). Haribon Publishing’s study of Death Note and the tragic hero covers more of that book. Isayama’s scene adds a practical condition: a choice reveals character only when the reader can see both things the character is choosing between.
“Give Up on Your Dream and Die”
Erwin cannot make the choice alone, so Isayama gives it to Levi. Levi tells him he has fought well and that the Corps came this far because of him. Then he says he will make the choice: Erwin gives up the dream and leads the recruits into hell, and Levi kills the Beast Titan (Attack on Titan Wiki: Perfect Game).
In Isayama’s account, Levi is answering a request. Isayama said Levi felt urged on by Erwin, as if Erwin were hoping to be told to “abandon my dream and go to hell,” and that Levi’s words are what allowed Erwin to become “the adult who prioritizes responsibility” (ComicBook.com). He also said he had always wanted to portray the two men as equals.
Sharing the choice changes what Levi carries out of the scene. He has promised to kill the Beast Titan, he has taken responsibility for his commander’s death, and he is the one who heard the confession. That last fact decides the story four chapters later.
A Speech That Tells the Truth
Erwin then tells the recruits the plan and what it will cost them. When a recruit points out that they will die either way, Erwin answers that their deaths still have meaning, because the soldiers who come after will give it to them (Attack on Titan Wiki: Chapter 80). As quoted from the anime by ComicBook.com, the speech builds to “We die trusting the living who follow to find meaning in our lives!” and ends with “My soldiers, rage! My soldiers, scream! My soldiers, fight!” (ComicBook.com: Erwin’s suicide mission).
English poetry has a famous charge of the same kind. Tennyson’s “The Charge of the Light Brigade” (1854) also sends cavalry into artillery, and its soldiers ride knowing that “Some one had blunder’d”: “Their’s not to reason why, / Their’s but to do and die” (Representative Poetry Online). Isayama’s recruits do ask why, and their commander answers them.
The speech also describes the man giving it. Moments earlier, Erwin gave up his own chance to learn the truth. He is about to die trusting the living to find it.
The Corps charges on horseback, firing signal flares to spoil the Beast Titan’s aim, while Levi uses the Titans standing nearby as cover to approach it. Erwin rides in front. A rock passes through his side, and he falls.
One Serum, Two Dying Soldiers
Levi reaches the Beast Titan, cuts it down and drags out the man inside, but another Titan carries the man off before Levi can finish (Wikipedia: Attack on Titan season 3). The battle ends with two soldiers dying. Armin Arlert, Eren’s childhood friend and the Corps’ young strategist, has been burned almost to death helping to capture Bertholdt Hoover, the human inside the Colossal Titan. Erwin is carried back by Floch Forster, the only known survivor of the charge (Wikipedia: List of Attack on Titan characters).
Levi has one dose of Titan serum. Whoever receives it becomes a Titan, and a Titan that eats someone like Bertholdt takes his power and returns to human form. Only one of the two can be saved.
Isayama gives both sides real arguments. Eren and Mikasa Ackerman plead for Armin, whose plans have saved the Corps before and who dreams of seeing the ocean. Floch argues for Erwin: it takes a devil to beat the Titans, and he believes he was spared so that he could bring that devil back (Attack on Titan Wiki: Midnight Sun episode). Levi’s own first decision is for Erwin. In Chapter 83, he says he will use the serum on the person who will save humanity (Attack on Titan Wiki: Chapter 83).
As Levi prepares the injection, Erwin, delirious, raises his arm away from the needle as if he were in a classroom. He asks how anyone knows there are no humans left outside the Walls. Levi remembers telling him to give up his dream. He also remembers his uncle, Kenny Ackerman, who said as he died that people can only keep going if they are drunk on something (Attack on Titan Wiki: Midnight Sun episode). Levi injects Armin.
Levi’s decision rests on what he heard in Chapter 80. Erwin has already given up the dream once, and in his delirium he is still asking the question behind it. Isayama said he drew those panels thinking “Everyone is a slave to something,” and that for Erwin, “only in death is there liberation.” Levi, he said, “accepted Erwin as human and chose to let him die” (ComicBook.com).
Afterward, Floch asks why. Levi answers that Erwin became a devil because the Corps needed one, that he had finally been set free, and that they were about to drag him back (Attack on Titan Wiki: Midnight Sun episode). In the next chapter, Levi admits that his personal feelings affected the decision (Attack on Titan Wiki: Chapter 85).
Two professional reviewers of the episode answered with different levels of certainty, which is a fair test of whether a dilemma works. Daniel Kurland of Den of Geek wrote, “I honestly don’t know who deserves this second chance more” (Den of Geek). James Beckett of Anime News Network reached a verdict: “So Levi makes the right choice and lets Erwin go” (Anime News Network).
The Answer Erwin Never Saw
Nine members of the Survey Corps survive the battle. In Chapter 85, four of them go to Eren’s house and enter the basement. In a desk drawer with a false bottom, they find three journals and a photograph with a note stating that humanity outside the Walls has not died out (Attack on Titan Wiki: Chapter 85).
That is the answer to the question Erwin asked with his arm raised, one chapter earlier. Isayama has said Erwin’s death at this point in the story was planned in advance (ComicBook.com). He gives the answer to the reader and withholds it from the character who wanted it most.
The placement completes the speech. Erwin told the recruits that the living would give their deaths meaning, and the living are the ones who open the drawer. A year later in the story, the survivors reach the ocean Armin dreamed of (Wikipedia: Attack on Titan season 3). Erwin’s dream is finished by other people after he is gone.
How to Write a Sacrifice That Costs Something
Six moves from Isayama’s two scenes transfer to any story in which a character gives something up.
1. Put a Selfish Want Under the Noble Cause
A character who serves a cause and wants nothing else has only his life to lose. Give him something private that the cause competes with. Erwin’s is a boy’s question about the world, tied to guilt over his father. Haribon Publishing’s breakdown of Meliodas and Elizabeth’s curse makes a related point about price in a romance, where the cure has to cost what the curse costs.
2. Reveal the Want in Stages
Isayama shows a smile in Chapter 51, a childhood in Chapter 55, an admission in Chapter 72 and a confession in Chapter 80. Each step tells the reader a little more than the other characters know, so the confession confirms what the reader already suspects.
3. Bring the Want Within Reach Before You Take It Away
The charge would cost Erwin less if the basement were far away. Put the thing the character wants in the same place as the thing he has to do, at the same hour.
4. Let Someone Else Share the Choice
Erwin needs Levi to say the words. A shared decision shows that the character cannot give the thing up easily, and it creates a second character who carries the consequences. Levi leaves the scene with a promise to keep and knowledge nobody else has.
5. Settle the Dilemma With What One Character Knows
A dilemma needs good arguments on both sides, and Isayama supplies them. The decision then turns on private knowledge from an earlier scene. Because the reader was present for that scene, Levi’s reversal follows from the story, even for readers who would have chosen differently.
6. Answer the Question After the Character Is Gone
The reader gets what Erwin wanted, one chapter too late for him. Paying off a dead character’s want through the living makes the loss specific, and it proves the character’s last argument.
Credit Where It Belongs
Attack on Titan was written and illustrated by Hajime Isayama and serialized in Kodansha’s Bessatsu Shōnen Magazine from September 2009 to April 2021, then collected in 34 volumes (Wikipedia: Attack on Titan). Wit Studio produced the first three seasons of the anime, which include every scene discussed here, and MAPPA produced the fourth. In the anime, Erwin is voiced by Daisuke Ono in Japanese and J. Michael Tatum in English, and Levi by Hiroshi Kamiya and Matthew Mercer (Wikipedia: List of Attack on Titan characters).
Isayama based Erwin’s design on Ozymandias, a character from Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons’s Watchmen (Attack on Titan Wiki: Erwin Smith), and modeled Levi on Rorschach from the same book (Wikipedia: List of Attack on Titan characters).
The interview quoted here appeared in the Attack on Titan Character Directory, published in Japan in August 2017 and released in English by Kodansha Comics in 2018 as the Attack on Titan Character Encyclopedia (Tokyo Otaku Mode). The quotations follow the fan translation reported by ComicBook.com, so their wording may differ from the official English edition.
Erwin Smith dies with his hand raised, asking a question in a classroom that is long gone. The answer is in a desk drawer one chapter later, and Isayama has the living open it.

